If you are thinking about building a membership idea to bring in an income later in life, there is one number that can talk you out of the whole thing before you have even begun: how many people you assume you need before it becomes worthwhile.

Look at a small list, or a membership with forty or fifty paying members, and it is easy to decide the whole thing is not working yet. So many people I talk with worry about outliving their savings, or feel wary of yet another system promising a residual income that never quite arrives.

Here is what nobody tells you before you choose what to build. The number of members you need has very little to do with how hard you market. It comes down to one decision, made long before you write a single lesson: which problem you chose to solve, and for whom.

Get that decision right, and a modest membership idea can pay you more, with far less stress, than a much bigger one built around the wrong problem.

The Maths Behind Every Membership Idea

Picture two people building an online income at roughly the same pace, putting in the same hours each week, with the same reasonable goal of clearing around a thousand US dollars a month.

One of them teaches a hobby, priced at ten dollars a month, and needs about a hundred paying members to reach that goal. The other solves a specific, costly problem for small business owners, priced at fifty dollars a month, and needs only twenty.

Same income. A fifth of the members, and a fifth of the support questions, emails and cancellations that come with each one.

Neither idea is wrong. A hobby is a lovely thing to teach, and plenty of people build a proper income doing exactly that. But when two people put in equal effort, the one solving a problem that matters to the buyer reaches their number first, with room to spare.

Why The Right Problem Beats The Bigger List

This is one of the ideas I picked up reading a piece Nick James wrote, and it changed how I think about choosing what to build. He has watched hundreds of people make the opposite call over the years: pick a topic first, because it feels enjoyable, then hope a paying crowd turns up to meet them there.

Nick James puts it plainly. The number of members you need is decided long before you write a single lesson, by which problem you chose to solve, and how much that problem is worth to the person paying for it.

Get that decision right, and a modest membership idea can pay you more, with far less stress, than a much bigger one built around the wrong problem.

Enjoying your topic still matters, since you may spend years working on it. It was never meant to carry the whole decision on its own, though.

Finding A Problem Worth Solving

Every niche hides a smaller, more urgent group inside it. They are not simply curious. They are anxious, and they are already spending money trying to fix what is bothering them.

Picture two people looking at the same subject. One wants a pleasant new hobby for the weekend. The other has just been told their pension will not stretch as far as they hoped, and wants a proper plan before anything else changes. Both are real people, but only one of them tends to buy quickly.

Look for that second group inside your own audience before you build anything, and speak to them directly in your very first lesson, your first email, and your opt-in page.

I have written about building trust with a smaller, more specific audience in other articles I have shared recently, and the same pattern keeps turning up: a modest, well chosen group of people will always outspend a much larger, vaguer crowd.

This applies just as much to those of us over fifty five, thinking hard about pensions that no longer stretch, healthcare costs eating into retirement, and whether it is too late to try something new. It rarely is, and a membership idea built around that exact worry will always outperform one aimed at everybody in general.

A Simple Test Before You Build Anything

You do not need months of research to check whether a membership idea has real legs. A few honest checks tell you plenty.

Search for the exact problem in forums, groups and reviews. If people are already describing the pain in their own words, unprompted, that pain is real.

Look for anyone half solving it already, even badly. A handful of clumsy or expensive attempts is often a healthy sign. It means people are already paying to fix this, just not very well yet.

Then build one simple page describing the promise, nothing else, and mention it to a small group of the right people. Real interest from strangers who owe you nothing tells you more in a single week than a month of guessing at your desk ever will.

Ask five people who fit your idea of the right reader one direct question. Would they pay monthly for a proper answer to this problem? Write down what they say, word for word if you can. Those exact words often become your best headline later.

What This Means For Your Next Project

None of this is about becoming smaller for its own sake. It is about being precise: one problem, for one identifiable group of people, that is worth paying to solve.

A membership idea built this way asks less of you every month. Fewer support questions, less content to keep producing, and a far shorter path to a proper residual income, one you can build in the small pockets of time you actually have, rather than the ones you wish you had.

Before you write a single lesson for your next project, ask the blunt question first. How much does this problem matter to the person paying for it, and who feels it most sharply?

Answer that plainly, and the size of the membership you need to build the income you want has a habit of shrinking considerably.

Whatever you decide to build next, take the time to choose the problem before you choose the platform. It is a quieter way to work, and for those of us building an income later in life, quieter is often exactly what we need.

Kind regards,

Angus

Calling All Frustrated Entrepreneurs –
Who Else Wants To Forget Selling 'Low Priced' One Off Digital Products Such As eBooks And…

Make Cash
Like Clockwork

Using A Passive Income System That Automatically Deposits Money Into Your Bank Account Effortlessly Every Month Instead.

Just enter your details below to discover how:

Privacy Policy: We value your privacy. You can unsubscribe from receiving future emails with 1 click at any time.